3 April 1819: Fanny Brawne, Complex Associations, & Poetry without Progress
Wentworth Place, Hampstead
On 3 April 1819, Fanny Brawne (along with her widowed mother and younger brother and sister) move into the Charles Wentworth Dilke’s half of Wentworth Place, a relatively new detached double-house in Hampstead. This puts them next door to Keats, who rents part of the other side of the building with his very close friend, Charles Brown and the other owner of Wentworth Place. This, then, puts the two young lovers next door to each other, separated only by a wall, through which they can hear the movements and sounds of each other. We can only imagine ears to the walls.
The Brawne family previously rent this same space in the summer of 1818. They have moved from another location in Hampstead, Elm Cottage. Fanny, about five years younger than Keats, becomes betrothed to Keats in October 1819, though they wished to keep it secret.
We do not know exactly when Keats meets Fanny,
but probably not long after he returns from his northern walking tour, mid-August
1818, but
before December 1818, and quite likely via the Dilke family. Keats and Fanny may have
declared
their love or intentions for each other Christmas day 1818, in the form of some kind
of
understanding,
but Keats still has an eye for beautiful women (at least off-handedly)
into spring 1819. Fanny is quick witted, very fashionable, attractive (but not stereotypically
so), social, and loves dances; Keats is at times possessive and jealous; and though
the two
seem to have some tiffs, Keats does not at first mind their differences. It is clear,
too,
that Fanny is sensitive to Keats’s feeling of loss over the death of his younger brother,
Tom, in December 1818, of consumption. Tom’s
death and Keats’s love for Fanny are likely linked by complex associations and feelings
of
loss, attachment, and love: Fanny lost her own father to the illness.
Most of Keats’s close friends do not approve of the relationship between Keats and Fanny. Rather unfairly, she is pegged as shallow and flirtatious, and a relationship with her is not viewed as being in Keats’s best interests. In fact, she seems supportive of Keats’s aspirations. But thinking ahead somewhat, there is the looming issue of finances: How was Keats to support himself, let alone a wife?*
Although Keats possibly composes a decently accomplished poem about this time—Ode on Indolence—he
nonetheless feels uncertain about his fate and worth as a poet. Unlike his greatest
poetry,
Ode on Indolence,
with its vague ruminations about rumination, lacks sharp or
contrastingly engaged determinations, perhaps reflecting not only Keats’s subject
but his
qualitative engagement with it; that is, there is little progress in the poem about
no
progress. That Keats decides not to publish the poem in his to-be 1820 volume might
suggest
his own downcast or at least indifferent assessment of the poem, even if at one point
later in
the year he declares to Sarah Jeffery he greatly enjoyed writing it (9 June); but
this is not
the same as making a strong declaration about its critical worth to other friends,
like Woodhouse, Reynolds, Brown, or Taylor.
Keats, then, struggles to find a way forward with his poetic progress, though he has
plenty
of simmering ideas about life, human nature, art, and imagination as a form of knowledge
that
overlap with subjects that will, shortly, end up in his poetry. At this general point,
Keats
does express some confidence in his ability to control and focus his creative temperament
in
light of an uncertain world; but, once more, putting this into poetry remains the
problem;
mid-April Keats in fact feels his poetry is at a standstill—I cannot do it yet with any
pleasure
(letters, 15 April). This will change very shortly—and remarkably so. Keats
remains primed with his continued belief in the principle of beauty and the power
of the
empathetic, capable imagination.
*And as usual, Keats’s finances are precarious: over 2-3 April, he withdraws significant funds (over 100 pounds, it seems) from his account tied to inheritance money, depleting at least one source of his income. This month Keats is also upset by one his closest friends, Benjamin Robert Haydon, when Haydon expresses how very hurt he is that Keats has not lived up to his promise to acquire some money for him; Keats attempts to explain his own waning finances to Haydon. Haydon’s life will be plagued by extreme financial and personal problems, and anything Keats can do only offers a moment of minor relief for Haydon. In the end, financial and artistic struggles contribute to Haydon’s eventual (and rather gruesome) suicide.